2018.06.29; Kazakhstan Offers a Model to Resolve North Korea Nuclear Arms Standoff | Best Countries | US News

   
       
   
 
   
                       
                       
 
               
           
               
             Kazakhstan's Lesson for North Korea    
       

The central Asian nation gave up nuclear weapons in exchange for promises of sovereignty and security.

                                               
                               
       
           
           

            ByTheodore Karasik, Contributor                    |Aug. 18, 2017, at 12:35 p.m.            

           
       
               
   
   
           
       
                   
   
                                                       
                   
               
                               
               
                           
       
               
   
   
       
           
                                                               
           
               
                    
                     Kazakhstan's Lesson for North Korea                    
               
           
           
   
   
           
       
       
                                                       
         
   
   
       
Share
        ×   
   
                                                                                               
           
       
   
 
   
       
                                                                                                                    KURCHATOV, KAZAKHSTAN, AUGUST 08:  A crumbling test structure stands at the Soviet-era Semipalatinsk Nuclear Test Site on Aug. 8, 2013, outside Kurchatov, Kazakhstan. Between 1949 and 1989, the Soviets conducted 456 nuclear tests, including 340 underground and 116 atmospheric tests on the site that spans an area just smaller than Belgium. (Photo by Ben Arnoldy/The Christian Science Monitor via Getty Images)       

A crumbling test structure stands at the Soviet-era Semipalatinsk nuclear test site in Kazakhstan in 2013. (Christian Science Monitor/Getty)

 
       
           

North Korea's pursuit of a deliverable nuclear-tipped ICBM aimed at the United States is the latest emerging threat to the American homeland. The U.N. Security Council has imposed another round of sanctions, which Russia and China supported.

       
       
               
                   
           
           
                                                                                                                               
   
       

                About Op-Ed       

                   

Views and opinions from around the world.

                       
                   
               
       
       
           

Other countries have dealt with their nuclear legacy differently. North Korea may want to look at Kazakhstan as a way out of its nuclear predicament. Kazakhstan is the leader in contending with its nuclear history in a smart and innovative way. Kazakhstan's opening of the world's first nuclear bank, supervised by the IAEA, at Oskemen's Ulba Metallurgical Plant, is a non-proliferation milestone. Low Enriched Uranium (LEU) for nuclear power stations is to be stored in a commercial first that makes the Central Asian country a leader in nuclear non-proliferation. With imagination, North Korea could have followed suit.

       
       
           

For 40 years, Kazakhstan was the test site for Soviet nuclear weapons. Hundreds of nuclear tests occurred and left a terrible toxic legacy. President Nursultan Nazarbayev ordered the closure of the Semipalatinsk site, and now that date, Aug. 29, is recognized by the United Nations as the International Day against Nuclear Tests. To be sure, Kazakhstan gave up its nuclear weapons in the wake of the Soviet collapse quickly after successful negotiation that established a non-proliferation first. No country has done more to meet the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons Treaty mission.

       
       
           

Kazakhstan's drive to rid the world of nuclear weapons started in the 1990s. The country sought guarantees of sovereignty and security from nuclear powers in exchange for giving up its nuclear weapons in the wake of the Soviet collapse, and it succeeded in receiving them. The United States, the United Kingdom, and Russia signed a 1994 Memorandum on Security Assurances in Connection with Kazakhstan's Accession to the NPT thus setting Astana on its non-proliferation trajectory that we see today. There is no reason why the U.S., China and Russia won't follow suit on North Korea.

       
       
           
   
       
       
           

Most of the former Soviet Union's nuclear tests occurred in Semipalatinsk, in northeastern Kazakhstan. By 1989, following the closure of the program due to protests, Semipalatinsk conducted 30 surface, 88 atmospheric, and 340 nuclear underground tests. Hundreds of thousands got sick with cancer and other diseases, or were born with birth defects, which resulted from radiation, and many died.

       
       
           

In 2006, the leaders from five Central Asia States – Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan and Uzbekistan – signed a treaty to create the Central Asian Nuclear Weapon-Free Zone (CANWFZ). The treaty forbids the development, manufacture, stockpiling, acquisition or possession of any nuclear explosive device within Central Asia. Peaceful uses of nuclear energy are permitted if placed under enhanced IAEA safeguards. CANWFZ is the first nuclear-weapon-free zone located entirely in the northern hemisphere.

       
       
           

Kazakhstan tried to persuade Iran to join CANWFZ as part of unlocking the stalled P5+1 negotiations in 2013. Astana hosted in February and April 2013 two specific rounds of discussions to convince Tehran to join Central Asia's non-proliferation regime. To push the issue, Kazakhstan's president formally announced his country's readiness to host the LEU Bank on its territory during the April 2009 joint press conference with Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad at his side in Astana, to show the international community that Astana hoped that countries like Iran would make use of the fuel bank. Tehran balked immediately, but Kazakhstan's desire to host such talks demonstrated that Astana is a valuable player in the global nuclear arena.

       
       
           
   
       
       
           

Kazakhstan's anti-nuclear weapons stance does not prevent it from being at the forefront of peaceful nuclear energy. It is the largest producer of uranium in the world, and the Kazakhs have proven expertise to secure nuclear facilities for the LEU Bank. The basic principle underlying the LEU bank is that buyers for civilian-use nuclear fuel will have access to stable and cost-effective supplies, avoiding the need for them to create their own enrichment cycles and instead expanding the nuclear fuel cycle.

       
       
           

Kazakhstan's enthusiasm for the fuel bank fits Astana's seriousness in halting nuclear proliferation. To this end, Astana wants all nuclear states to prevent further proliferation by adhering to the NPT.

       
       
           

With Kazakhstan's non-permanent seat in the UNSC and upcoming chairmanship of the rotating chair in January 2018, Astana is in a position to influence LEU banking and policy discussion to resolve the North Korean nuclear crisis. Pyongyang needs to view Kazakhstan as an example of a responsible nuclear non-proliferation state, and as a route out of the current standoff.

       
   
           

                Tags:                    North Korea,                    Kazakhstan,                    nuclear weapons,                    nuclear power,                    diplomacy,                    world news,                    Best Countries           

           
           
       
                           Theodore Karasik        , Ph.D. is an adjunct senior fellow at the Lexington Institute, a national security think tank. He studies global security and ethnic conflict... full bio »
                   
       
               
               
   

        Recommended Articles   

                       
       

                                    The 25 Best Countries in the World                       

                                   
           

                Deidre McPhillips                                |                Jan. 23, 2018           

           

Based on global opinion, these 25 nations are the world's best.

       
   
                       
       

                                    U.S. Slipping in Leadership, Relevance, According to Best Countries Survey                       

                                   
           

                Kevin Drew                                |                Jan. 23, 2018           

           

Donald Trump’s first year as president rattles world’s confidence, while quiet, stable Switzerland remains the No. 1 country.

       
   
                       
       

                                    10 Interesting Facts From the 2018 Best Countries Report                       

                                   
           

                Deidre McPhillips                                |                Jan. 23, 2018           

           

A survey of more than 21,000 people worldwide illustrates the state of global affairs.

       
   
       
       
                       
       

                                    LeMond, Holocaust Survivors Ride to Celebrate Jewish Life                       

                                   
           

                June 29, 2018           

           

Three-time Tour de France winner Greg LeMond, two Holocaust survivors and dozens of others took part in a symbolic ride from Auschwitz-Birkenau to a Jewish cultural center in Poland to support the renewal of Jewish life.

       
   
                       
       

                                    3 Killed in Attack on West African Counterterror Force's HQ                       

                                   
           

                June 29, 2018           

           

3 killed in attack on West African counterterror force's headquarters, with several wounded.

       
   
           
       

                                    U.S., UK, Norway Call for End to 'Horrendous Abuses' in South Sudan                       

                                   
           

                June 29, 2018           

           

       
   
                       
       

                                    Canadian Populist Doug Ford Sworn in as Ontario Province Premier                       

                                   
           

                June 29, 2018           

           

       
   
           
       

                                    Palestinians Say 13-Year-Old Killed Along Border With Israel                       

                                   
           

                June 29, 2018           

           

Gaza health officials say two Palestinians including a teenage boy were killed and scores wounded by Israeli fire as weekly border rallies organized by the Islamic militant group that rules the territory continued.

       
   
       
       
           
       

                                    Number of Displaced Triples to 160,000 During Fighting in South Syria: UNHCR                       

                                   
           

                June 29, 2018           

           

       
   
           
       

                                    Polish Stork Vanishes From GPS but Delivers Huge Phone Bill                       

                                   
           

                June 29, 2018           

           

A Polish environmental that was using a GPS transmitter to track the migratory movements of a stork stopped getting signals from the bird in the spring.

       
   
                   
       
             
         
       
           
   
           
     
       

2018 Best Countries

                     
   
   
       
   
               
   
           

        Recent Articles   

   
     
                               
     
       
                 
       

          Ad Content by Vanguard

       

          Liquidity: Factor Investing's Hidden Gem       

     
   
   
                   
                Read More Articles   
   
   
         
       
             
 
  
 
   
   
 
   
 
 
     
       
         
                       

Best
Countries

         
         

In partnership with and          

       
       
         
  • Best Countries is a rankings, news and analysis project created to capture how countries are perceived on a global scale.  The rankings evaluate 80 countries across 24 rankings drawn from a survey of more than 21,000 global citizens, measuring 75 dimensions that have the potential to drive trade, travel and investment and directly affect national economies.             
  •